What happens when a research study is completed? How are the results shared? And who checks whether the conclusions are well supported by the evidence? In this blog, we explain how scientific findings are published, what peer review and preprints are, and why the distinction matters when reading news about research into ME/CFS.

Not all scientific articles are the same

Before looking at peer review and preprints, it is useful to know that there are different types of scientific articles. They do not all address the same kinds of research questions.

  • Original research article: describes a new study. Researchers explain what they investigated, how they conducted the study and what results they found.
  • Case study: describes, for example, in detail the symptoms, treatment or course of illness of one patient or a small number of patients. This can provide new insights, but the findings cannot automatically be generalised to other patients.
  • Literature review: provides an overview of what previous studies have found about a particular topic.
  • Systematic review: researchers search for and assess existing studies on a specific research question using a predefined method. This helps them provide as complete and thorough an overview as possible of the available evidence.
  • Meta-analysis: sometimes researchers can statistically combine the results of different studies. This can provide a clearer picture of what those studies show when considered together.
  • There are also shorter types of publication, such as a letter, in which researchers may respond to previously published research or briefly discuss new findings.

Research findings can be shared in different ways. In science, peer review and preprints are two of the most common ways of sharing new findings. Although both are intended to disseminate knowledge, they differ in terms of publication speed, scientific scrutiny and accessibility.

What is peer review?

Before a scientific article is published in an academic journal, it is usually assessed by other experts in the same field. This process is called peer review. The experts who assess the article are known as peer reviewers.

They critically evaluate the research. Is the method used appropriate for the research question? Have the data been analysed correctly? Are the conclusions adequately supported by the results? Are there any problems or errors that the researchers may have overlooked?

The reviewers then provide their recommendations to the journal. An article may be accepted, may need to be revised first, or may be rejected. If reviewers have comments, researchers are usually given the opportunity to respond and revise their article. Sometimes only minor improvements are needed, but in other cases more substantial changes or additional analyses may be required.

This process can take several months, and sometimes even more than a year. As a result, it may take some time before research findings become widely available to the public. For many articles, you can see when the journal first received the manuscript and when it was eventually accepted. A short or long review period does not, in itself, say anything about the quality of the research.

Peer review therefore adds an extra layer of scientific scrutiny before an article is published. However, reviewers can also miss errors. A peer-reviewed article is not automatically error-free, and scientific scrutiny remains important even after publication.

Transparency also helps. Researchers aim to describe as clearly as possible how they conducted their study and how they arrived at their findings. Research data cannot always be made fully public, for example because of privacy considerations.

Researchers therefore try to make as much information about their research available as possible, so that others can understand how the study was conducted and assess the findings. They often follow guidelines to make data as findable, accessible, interoperable and reusable as possible (the so-called FAIR principles). This allows other researchers to continue evaluating the research and, where possible, repeat the analyses.

What is a preprint?

Sometimes researchers want to share their findings before going through the peer review process. This may be because there is considerable interest in a particular topic or because they want other researchers to review their work at an early stage. In such cases, they can make their article available online as a preprint.

A preprint has not yet undergone the full peer review process required for publication in an academic journal. This means that other experts have not yet assessed the research in the same way as they would an article published in a journal following peer review. Errors may still be discovered, or questions may remain about the methods, analyses or conclusions. A preprint may be revised later in response to feedback.

This is important to bear in mind when following news about ME/CFS. A preprint may contain interesting new findings and provide early insight into emerging research. However, particularly when findings are striking or unexpected, it is wise to interpret the conclusions with caution and look at whether further research confirms the results.

Why does the distinction matter?

The difference between a preprint and a peer-reviewed article lies in when the findings are shared and how much scrutiny they have undergone at that point.

  • Peer-reviewed article: other experts have assessed the article before publication. The article may have been revised in response to their feedback, which can improve its reliability and quality. However, this does not guarantee that the research is free from errors or uncertainties.
  • Preprint: the article and its findings are available more quickly, but the work has not yet undergone full peer review. Its content and conclusions may still change following feedback or peer review.

Peer review is therefore one of the ways in which scientific research is scrutinised. However, assessing research findings requires more than that. The type of study, the methods used, the number of participants, potential sources of bias, and whether other studies report similar findings all play a role.

About the Authors

This blog is part of a blog series in which the Communication and Implementation Working Group of the ZonMw ME/CFS Research Programme takes you step by step into the world of scientific research. The series is intended for people with ME/CFS, their loved ones, and anyone interested in learning more about the condition. We explain what scientific research is, how it works, and the role it plays in improving our understanding of ME/CFS. You can find the other blogs in this series via the main menu.







This blog was written by Inge van Putten and Sebastiaan Stam and was developed through collaboration between the following parties within the ME/CFS Research Programme:

  • ME/cvs Vereniging
  • MECVS Nederland
  • MECFS Lines consortium
  • NMCB-consortium
  • ZonMw